Top 8 Best Motive Alternatives (2026)
Rules, prices and device details on this page were checked October 2026 against the official sources listed at the bottom. Where a provider doesn't publish a number, we say so instead of guessing.
Motive is one of the biggest names in trucking technology. Its S1 filing reported nearly 100,000 customers as of September 30, 2025. But it isn't the right fit for everyone. Some fleets want lower prices, others want shorter contracts, and some need features Motive doesn't focus on. Here are eight alternatives, with prices where they're public. Details were checked October 2026.
Why Look for Alternatives
- Price. Motive quotes privately, and bundles with cameras can get expensive.
- Contracts. Motive's terms renew for 12 months unless you cancel at least 30 days before renewal.
- Fit. A one truck operation may not need AI dash cams and spend management.
- Specific needs. Like heavy maintenance tracking, mixed vehicle fleets or open data platforms.
Comparison Table
| Alternative | Best for | Published price |
|---|---|---|
| Samsara | Larger fleets wanting a full platform | Quote only |
| Geotab | Mixed fleets and data | Through resellers |
| Verizon Connect | Service fleets | Quote only |
| HOS247 | Owner operators on a budget | $19 a month; device free with annual pay |
| Garmin eLog | No monthly fee | $249.99 one time |
| Matrack ELD | Low cost ELD plus GPS | $19.95 to $24.95 a month |
| BIT ELD | Simple, low cost logs | $40 a month or $400 a year |
| Teletrac Navman | Construction and mixed equipment | Quote only |
Top 8 Alternatives
1. Samsara
Samsara is Motive's most direct competitor. It ended fiscal 2026 with $1.89 billion in annual recurring revenue, much larger than Motive by revenue. It offers ELD, AI dash cams, GPS, maintenance and equipment tracking in one platform. It's a strong choice for growing and large fleets. Pricing is quote only and contracts are often multi year. See our Motive vs Samsara comparison.
Pros: broad features, polished software, strong for large accounts. Cons: may be more than a small fleet needs, and contracts tend to be long. Switch from Motive if: you're growing past 50 trucks and want one vendor for everything.
2. Geotab
Geotab is known for an open platform and deep data. It works well for fleets with a mix of trucks, vans and cars, and the Geotab Drive app provides ELD logs. Most customers buy through resellers, so price and support vary.
Pros: open platform, huge marketplace of add ons, flexible reporting. Cons: the experience depends on your reseller. Switch from Motive if: you run a mixed fleet or want to build custom reports with your own data.
3. Verizon Connect
Verizon Connect is popular with service fleets thanks to strong dispatch and scheduling tools. It also offers an ELD and dash cams. It's a good alternative if your fleet is more vans than semis.
Pros: job scheduling, dispatch and a big support network. Cons: quote only pricing and add on fees. Switch from Motive if: most of your vehicles are service vans visiting customer sites.
4. HOS247
HOS247 is a budget option at $19 a month, with the device free if you pay annually. It covers ELD logs, IFTA mileage and GPS tracking. It's a good fit for owner operators and small fleets who don't need cameras.
Pros: low, clear pricing. Cons: fewer advanced safety features. Switch from Motive if: you're paying for features you don't use and want to cut costs.
5. Garmin eLog
Garmin eLog costs $249.99 one time with no monthly subscription for logs. It's a simple ELD for drivers who just want compliance. It doesn't offer fleet tracking features like the big platforms, so it's best for owner operators. See our Garmin eLog review.
Pros: no subscription for logs. Cons: no fleet dashboard for managers. Switch from Motive if: you're a single truck owner operator who only needs compliant logs.
6. Matrack ELD
Matrack offers ELD plans from $19.95 to $24.95 a month and includes GPS tracking. It's a common choice for small fleets that want logs and location at a low price.
Pros: low price with GPS included. Cons: fewer premium features. Switch from Motive if: you need logs and location for a small fleet on a budget.
7. BIT ELD
BIT ELD costs $40 a month or $400 a year. It's a simple, low cost logging option with basic fleet tools.
Pros: simple, predictable pricing. Cons: basic feature set. Switch from Motive if: you want straightforward logs with an annual price.
8. Teletrac Navman
Teletrac Navman suits construction and mixed equipment fleets, tracking trucks alongside heavy equipment. It offers ELD and AI video, with quote only pricing.
Pros: strong for trucks plus heavy equipment in one view. Cons: quote only pricing and contract terms. Switch from Motive if: you run a construction fleet with yellow iron alongside trucks.
What to Compare Before You Switch
Every alternative has tradeoffs. Before you pick one, compare them on the things that made you look away from Motive in the first place.
Total cost over 3 years
Monthly price is only part of the cost. Add hardware, cameras, installation and any early exit fees from your current contract. A $19 a month ELD and a quote only platform with cameras are very different products, so compare like with like. If you only need logs, a budget ELD will cost far less over 3 years. If you need cameras and coaching, compare the full platforms.
Contract terms
Ask every vendor about contract length, auto renewal and cancellation notice. Budget ELDs like HOS247 often offer monthly or annual plans. Enterprise platforms usually expect multi year terms. If flexibility matters, see our no contract ELD guide.
Driver app
Motive's app is familiar to many drivers. Switching to a clunky app can frustrate drivers and cause log mistakes. Have a couple of drivers test the new app before you sign.
Safety video
If you rely on Motive's AI dash cams, your choices narrow to platforms with comparable video, mainly Samsara, Verizon Connect, Teletrac Navman, or a camera specialist like Lytx paired with another ELD. See our best dash cams for trucks guide.
Spend management
If you use the Motive Card, you'll need a new fuel card too. Our best fuel cards for truckers guide compares options.
Integrations
List the systems connected to Motive today, like dispatch, payroll or maintenance, and confirm the new provider supports them.
Feature Comparison
| Alternative | ELD | GPS tracking | AI dash cams | Maintenance tools |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Samsara | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Geotab | Yes | Yes | Through partners and add ons | Yes |
| Verizon Connect | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| HOS247 | Yes | Yes | Check current offer | Basic |
| Garmin eLog | Yes | No fleet tracking | No | No |
| Matrack ELD | Yes | Yes | Check current offer | Basic |
| BIT ELD | Yes | Basic | No | Basic |
| Teletrac Navman | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Feature lists change often, so confirm with each vendor before you buy.
Owner Operators vs Fleets
For an owner operator, the decision is usually simple. If you only need compliant logs, a budget ELD like HOS247 or Garmin eLog will cost far less than a full platform, and you won't miss the extra features. If you lease onto a carrier, check which ELD the carrier requires before you buy anything. For fleets, the choice is more about safety programs, integrations and how much time managers spend in the dashboard each day. A fleet that actively coaches drivers with video should look at Samsara, Verizon Connect or Teletrac Navman. A fleet that mainly needs logs and location can save a lot with Matrack or HOS247.
How We Picked These Alternatives
We focused on ELDs and platforms that are on the FMCSA registered list, serve US trucking or service fleets, and publish enough information to compare fairly. We included both full platforms and low cost ELDs because people leave Motive for very different reasons. A 300 truck carrier unhappy with renewal terms and a one truck owner operator who wants to stop paying for cameras need different answers. Prices shown are what each company publishes, checked October 2026. Where pricing is quote only, we say so rather than guess. We didn't accept payment for placement, and we'll update this list as prices and products change.
Who Should Stay With Motive
Switching has costs too. If your drivers like the app, your safety program depends on Motive's video and coaching tools, and the price at renewal is reasonable, staying may be the smart move. Use alternative quotes to negotiate. Many fleets get a better renewal price simply by showing they've done their homework. Ask for a price lock for the full term, a shorter renewal period and clear cancellation terms in writing.
Best Alternative by Use Case
- Best full platform: Samsara.
- Best for mixed fleets: Geotab.
- Best for service fleets: Verizon Connect.
- Best budget ELD: HOS247.
- Best with no monthly fee: Garmin eLog.
- Best for construction: Teletrac Navman.
For more budget picks, see our cheapest ELD guide and best ELDs for small fleets.
How to Switch From Motive
Check your renewal date and give written notice at least 30 days before it. Export at least 6 months of logs and supporting documents before you cancel. Make sure drivers have the current day plus the previous 7 days of logs on the new ELD or on paper. Our guide to switching ELD providers walks through every step.
Bottom Line
Motive is a strong product, especially for safety focused trucking fleets. But if price, contracts or fit are issues, there are good alternatives at every level, from full platforms to $19 a month apps. Compare a few, run a pilot and read the contract before you switch. See our best ELD devices roundup for more options.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best alternative to Motive?
Samsara is the closest full platform alternative. For budget options, HOS247, Matrack and Garmin eLog are popular.
Is Samsara better than Motive?
It depends on your fleet. Samsara is larger and strong for enterprise fleets. Motive is popular with trucking fleets of all sizes.
Can I cancel Motive anytime?
Motive terms renew for 12 months unless you give notice at least 30 days before renewal. Check your own contract.
Is there a Motive alternative with no monthly fee?
Yes. Garmin eLog costs $249.99 one time with no monthly fee for logs.
Sources
All prices, terms and registration details were checked October 2026 on the pages below. Providers change pricing often, so confirm before you buy.